Ways to join
Standard of Truth
$9.99/month
- Other benefits
For members only
201 episodes
- S3E22 Washington’s “Unanimous Election” (CTRI)We record on Veterans Day, the day after Edmund Fitzgerald Day, so Gordon Lightfoot gets his due. Washington wins every electoral vote, all 69, and the new system still nearly breaks. Each elector casts two votes on one ballot, and the runner-up becomes vice president. So in March 1789 Madison writes Jefferson that electors threw away a vote or two so John Adams wouldn't tie Washington. New York argues over its electors so long it casts none, and Virginia can't agree on senators. We cover why th
- S2E20 D&C 45 Part 7 (STC)We finally put a bow on D&C 45. First we mourn a red zone loss to Utah and find the bright side of a coaching buyout. In the Phebe Draper Palmer Brown Mailbag, Steve, writes from Reading, Pennsylvania, where he is raising two grandkids who endure us in the car. He was also at the Eagles game where fans threw snowballs at Santa, and the crack research staff finds out why. Gerrit sets an old sermon declaring the heathen lost against a revelation promising they will be redeemed. We cover the Millen
- S2E19 D&C 45 Part 6 (STC)We try to wrap up D&C 45. Key word: try. First, toy car keys, fake video game controllers, and a letter from a half-marathoner with twin daughters serving in Natal, Brazil and Bakersfield, California.Verse 54 promises the heathen nations will be redeemed, in an age when preachers taught the unevangelized were bound for hell. We read Brigham Young's 1852 and 1860 sermons on faithful Methodists, Catholics, and heathens receiving glory, and share a John MacArthur clip. If God is actually our Father
- S2E18 D&C 45 Part 5 (STC)We stay in Doctrine and Covenants 45 and discuss Zechariah, the Second Coming, Mount of Olives spliting, the Jews ask "What are these wounds in thine hands?" and Jesus answers, "I am Jesus that was crucified." Gerrit untangles "they that have watched for iniquity" (it meansdefending sin, not spotting it) and lands on one of his favorite verses: the heathen nations shall be redeemed, a thunderclap for 1831 saints who did not yet have D&C 76. That sends us into the question Christianity cannot ans
- S2E17 D&C 45 Part 4In part four of our Doctrine and Covenants 45 series we finally dig into the section itself, and it turns out to be the inside story of Matthew 24. Gerrit shows what the revelation restores: the disciples asked about the Second Coming because they saw the separation of spirit and body as bondage, and Jesus noted that their enemies swore the temple could never fall. That sends us to Rabshakeh, the Assyrian general with the best trash talk in the Bible, and an army that woke up dead. We also cover
- S3E21 President Biden, Vice President TrumpThe Constitution is ratified, and now someone has to actually run an election. We dig into Article 2, Section 1 and the design flaw the founders didn’t see coming: electors cast two votes with no way to mark which was for president, and the runner-up became vice president. Why did the framers put layers between the people and the presidency? Their fear of anarchy gets a modern tour through Somalia, Libya, and Hurricane Katrina.If you are interested in joining us in 2027 in Palmyra and Kirtland,
- S3E20 Rome, Ruin, and the Republic, New York Finally RatifiesThe Samuel Osgood mailbag brings a big question from Michael: knowing what they'd think of us now, would the Founders be more or less hopeful than they were about Rome? We discuss that the Founders would marvel at America's economy and power while recoiling at how much authority sits with the president and the standing army, only Hamilton really wanted that, and maybe only for Washington. Along the way we talk about why the Soviet constitution reads like a "banger" yet guaranteed nothing (separa
- S2E16 D&C 45 Part 3In this episode we continue our discussion of Doctrine & Covenants Section 45 and its message of hope for the Second Coming. Richard shares why verses 3-5 are his favorite in all of scripture: the Savior as our advocate, pleading our cause not for what we've done but for what He did. Gerrit connects it to D&C 29 and Matthew 24, unpacking Christ's three questions about the signs of His coming.If you are interested in joining us in 2027 in Palmyra and Kirtland, August 1st through August 7th, click
- S3E19 Poughkeepsie or Bust: New York Faces the ConstitutionNew York didn't want to ratify, and definitely didn't want to do it in Poughkeepsie. We dig into the strangest ratification fight yet: a Dutch-rooted colony of landed gentry, a governor (George Clinton) who championed the common man, and anti-federalists like Melancton Smith warning that two governments taxing one people would hollow the states into a powerless Roman Senate.If you are interested in joining us in 2027 in Palmyra and Kirtland, August 1st through August 7th, click on the link below
- S3E18 Away With Your President: Patrick Henry's Last StandHappy Constitution Day! In this episode, we dig into Patrick Henry's fiery opposition at the Virginia Ratification Convention, his warning that a president commanding a standing army could crown himself king, and that too few representatives invite corruption. Along the way: whether an armed citizenry could really stop the modern military, the strange saga of John Tyler (the accidental "Whig" who governed as a Democrat and became the most hated president of his day), the 2010 Bell, California pa
- S2E15 D&C 45 Part 2This episode of Search These Commandments detours before ever reaching D&C 45's first verse, diving into 1831 anti-Mormon sentiment from an unexpected source: the Catholic press. Gerrit reads wild period accounts branding "old Joe" Smith a gingerbread-peddling schemer and casting Sidney Rigdon as a mysterious "treasure dreamer" recruited to turn a digging scam into a religion, claims with zero historical support. We unpack why persecution context matters for understanding Joseph's revelations, c
- S2E14 D&C 45 Part 1Latter-day Saints, uniquely among 1830s Christians, believed Jesus was coming back soon. We discuss why that premillennial belief made Joseph Smith's followers instant outliers, why "when is Jesus coming?" is the question most ripe for false prophets, and why Utah (by a landslide) leads the nation in Google searches for "signs of the second coming." Along the way: Patrick Ewing quotes, Big 12 week zero picks, a South African pastor's failed prophecy, and a taste test of strawberry Yoo-hoo. RIf y
- S3E17 Can Your President Become King?Patrick Henry warned Virginia that the Constitution would create an unstoppable tyrant with an army at his command. In this episode, we dive deep into his apocalyptic speech against ratification. We examine his central fear: a president with control of the military could simply decide to stay in power, and what would actually stop him? Is Patrick Henry's paranoia justified, or did the Founders get it right? We explore how this concern isn't merely hypothetical, examining real historical examples
- S3E16 Slaveholders Against the Slave TradeAs the Virginia Ratification Convention debates the Constitution, Henry monopolizes the floor for hours at a time, opposing every article, the executive, the courts, the very idea that a crisis exists at all. We dig into the stunning debate where George Mason, owner of over 100 slaves, condemns the Atlantic slave trade as "diabolical" and argues Virginia shouldn't ratify because the Constitution allows it to continue for 20 years. We also discuss James Madison's practical defenses, the brutal ma
- S3E15 Jefferson, Henry, and the Fight Over God and GovernmentWe continue to press on through the ratification of the Constitution, landing in Virginia, the biggest, richest, and most stubborn state of them all. Thomas Jefferson pushes for a Bill of Rights and gives a savage takedown of Patrick Henry, the greatest orator who ever lived, and rotten-hearted to boot, and the strange grace of Adams and Jefferson dying friends on the same Fourth of July.If you are interested in joining us in 2027 in Palmyra and Kirtland, August 1st through August 7th, click on
- S2E13 D&C 43 Part 3 and D&C 44We unpack the two kinds of false revelation, why every family should study its opening verses, and how the section expands into one of scripture's most vivid portraits of the Second Coming. We also discuss the case for premillennialism against a post-millennial world, a staggered first resurrection, and the promised endowment of power. We also cover D&C 44 and share how Joseph models instant obedience, firing off urgent letters to Martin Harris and brother Hyrum telling the elders to gather. If
- S2E12 D&C 43 Part 2In Part 2 of our look at Doctrine and Covenants Section 43 we trace how early Kirtland saints wrestled with false manifestations of the Spirit and rival revelators like Hiram Page. Drawing on Joseph Smith's 1831 letter to his brother Hyrum and his later counsel to John S. Carter, we unpack the Lord's unmistakable answer: revelation for the whole church comes only through the prophet, even if the prophet were to fall. Along the way we spar with sola scriptura, the closed-canon question, the Monta
- S2E11 D&C 43 Part 1Before we jump into Section 43, we take the long way around by way of a second-century heretic named Montanus, the state of Montana, and a lightning-struck circus elephant in Dillon. Richard battles what may or may not be consumption while Gerrit explains why the "sola scriptura" argument and the tired Galatians 1:8 attack both collapse the moment you remember the New Testament runs on continuing revelation.The real catalyst: a woman named Hubble in Kirtland, testifying the Book of Mormon is tru
- S3E14 Washington’s Warning to AmericaWas the United States truly on the brink of collapse under the Articles of Confederation, or were leaders like George Washington overstating the crisis? We explore Washington's powerful warnings of "anarchy," John Hancock's pivotal role in Massachusetts, and the compromises that ultimately secured ratification. Along the way, we connect eighteenth-century debates over taxes, monopolies, representation, and federal power to the political questions Americans are still wrestling with today.If you a
- S2E10 D&C 42 Part 4At long last, we put D&C 42 to bed. Turns out the "law of the church" was received in two parts, and the second half, hidden behind a question that never made it into your Doctrine and Covenants, is what makes verses 74 and on make more sense. We dig into church discipline, keeping sins private versus public, and why poor Bishop Edward Partridge keeps catching strays. Then we detour into the wild world of 19th-century marriage: why divorce required an act of the legislature and how Andrew Jackso
- S2E9 D&C 42 Part 3Drawing on the manuscript versions, they recover the specific questions that prompted the revelation, context the published text leaves out. Along the way: Symonds Ryder, the revelation's scribe who later apostatized, and the dubious half-century-later claim that he left over a misspelled name; Ezra Booth; why the Lord organized Saints into geographic congregations "in consequence of the enemy"; and the early scriptural basis for supporting full-time church servants from consecrated property. Pl
- S3E13 A Republic, If You Can Keep ItThe ratification fight continues as we cover Massachusetts' razor-thin 187-168 vote, John Hancock's late-but-decisive endorsement, and Maryland's ratification despite Luther Martin's vow to "be hanged" before approving it. Then it's a deep dive into Madison's Federalist No. 10, why factionalism is poison to republics, why liberty and faction are inseparable ("liberty is to faction what air is to fire"), and how partisanship erodes public virtue. Tangents: NBA Finals heartbreak, Hack-a-Shaq strat
- S3E12 The Umbrella of Discontent: Anti-Federalism's Many FacesIn this episode of Condemned to Repeat It, we dig into the fierce, chaotic fight over ratifying the Constitution, centered on Massachusetts, the populous, revolution-hardened state whose rejection could have killed the whole project. We discuss why Anti-Federalism was less a single movement than an umbrella term spanning everyone from Elbridge Gerry, who simply wanted a Bill of Rights attached, to the Daniel Shays faction, who opposed a stronger federal government on principle. Along the way we
- S2E8 D&C 42 Part 2In this episode we continue exploring how a rapidly growing, less-than-a-year-old church established its earliest standards of belief, conduct, and discipline. We discuss why early excommunication was swift but also quickly reversible, drawing surprising comparisons to 1830s Baptist and Methodist congregations (where drunkenness topped the list of reasons members were cut off), and unpack what it meant to be an authorized representative versus a private member sharing the gospel. The conversatio
- S3E11 Enumerated Rights for an Energetic GovernmentWe begin with a discussion of why populous, divided states like Pennsylvania endured weeks of acrimonious debate (including suppressed newspapers and a delegates' boarding house surrounded by angry Philadelphia dock workers) while small neighbors like Delaware, New Jersey, and Georgia ratified unanimously, each for self-interested reasons, from Senate equality to protection against trade-taxing giants and frontier threats. The conversation digs into the core anti-Federalist objection (the missin
- S3E10 Conceived in Liberty Federalist Number 1After opening banter about Richard's son Parker's graduation and a French-Canadian plumber sharing Richard's name, Gerrit returns to a sore spot with Hamilton proposal for an elected monarch for life commanding a large standing army, a fact that lent real weight to Anti-Federalist fears. Gerrit maps the opposition geographically and personally, from Governor Clinton in New York to Elbridge Gerry in Massachusetts to the Virginia trio of Richard Henry Lee, George Mason, and Patrick Henry, and land
- S3E9 Brutus, Montesquieu, and the Trouble with Big RepublicsThe episode centers on George Mason's 1776 Virginia Declaration of Rights as the philosophical backbone of the eventual Bill of Rights, walking through its sixteen sections and tying each one to the British abuses the colonists had just lived through. From there, the conversation turns to the Anti-Federalist camp, examining how figures like Edmund Randolph, Luther Martin, and the pseudonymous "Brutus" drew on Montesquieu to argue that a republic spread across so vast a territory could only colla
- S3E8 Ben Franklin's Final PleaThe centerpiece is Benjamin Franklin's closing speech at the Convention, read aloud by James Wilson, urging delegates to doubt their own infallibility and sacrifice personal objections for the public good, a plea echoed by Gouverneur Morris and Alexander Hamilton, who signed despite serious reservations because the alternative was anarchy. Gerrit maps the geography of opposition: New York as an Anti-Federalist hotbed, Rhode Island refusing even to send delegates, and rural Americans across every
- S3E7 The Constitution, Take-It-or-Leave-ItUsing analogies that range from ward party planning disasters to the universal frustration of someone asking "did you check your car?" while you're hunting for lost keys, the hosts explore why three delegates (Edmund Randolph, George Mason, and Elbridge Gerry) refused to sign the Constitution and why others, like Charles Pinckney, signed despite serious reservations. Along the way they unpack the founders' deep fear of standing armies, the Lockean logic against enumerating rights, the strategic
- S2E7 D&C 42 Part 1In this episode, we begin our discussion of section 42 of the doctrine and covenants. We begin by reviewing the requirements for membership in the Methodist Church and review the questions new converts are asked by Missionaries before they are baptized.Sign up for our free monthly email: https://standardoftruthpodcast.substack.comIf you have any questions or possible topics of discussion for upcoming podcasts, please email us at: questions@standardoftruthpodcast.com
- S2E6 D&C 41 Part 5In this episode, Richard celebrates Joni's upcoming baptism after the podcast helped answer her questions, then Gerrit unpacks the real backstory of D&C 41: Lehman Copley's offer to build Joseph Smith a house and bankroll him if he'd settle in Thompson, Ohio. Instead of accepting, Joseph follows the Lord's unexplained "no", and is spared when Copley apostatizes months later and turns on the Saints. Gerrit traces Joseph's growth from the 17-year-old tempted by the gold plates, to the 1828 Joseph
- S2E5 D&C 41 Part 4In this episode, we begin with the wild scene Joseph Smith walked into when he arrived in Kirtland with members sliding across floors pretending to sail boats to the Lamanites, wielding imaginary Swords of Laban, baptizing ghosts, and throwing themselves into snowbanks. We explore how Satan's counterfeits were so convincing that even faithful members like Levi Hancock were fooled, why good people make the most dangerous tools of deception, and what all of this chaos has to do with Edward Partrid
- S3E6 The Convention's Darkest DebateIn this episode, we pick up right where we left off with the Constitutional Convention's debate over suffrage, slavery, and who gets to be an American. Franklin makes a stirring case for the common man, Gouverneur Morris delivers arguably the most powerful anti-slavery speech of the entire convention, and we wrestle with the uncomfortable question of whether the founders who stayed quiet on slavery were pragmatists or cowards.Along the way, we sneak in George Mason's 2006 NCAA tournament run, Ka
- S3E5 Less Popular Than Nickelback: Congress and the Suffrage DebateIn this episode, we open with March Madness brackets and Gerrit's son's mission call announcement before somehow working in WrestleMania 42 betting odds then settle into the Constitutional Convention's debate over suffrage: who gets to vote, and who gets to decide. We also discuss how the founders' arguments turn out to be surprisingly modern, Congress clocks in at a humbling 15% approval rating (well below Nickelback), and Richard sneaks in a free tip on sales incentive structures along the way
- S2E4 D&C 41 Part 3In this episode of Search These Commandments we begin with a painfully honest March Madness bracket update before diving back into Doctrine and Covenants 41 and the chaotic early days of the Church in Kirtland. Gerrit unpacks an early anti-Mormon attack on Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon, expose the recycled logic behind familiar objections to the Restoration, and explore the bizarre spiritual excesses that erupted among some early converts after the missionaries left town. Who shot Alexander Ham
- S2E3 D&C 41 Part 2In this episode, Richard battles through a flu-ridden, barely-alive condition to dive back into early anti-Mormon arguments, Sidney Rigdon, and the remarkable claim that you should apparently trust the Bible completely but never pray to God about whether anything else is true. Please join us in our Standard of Truth Dead and in Hell March Madness Bracket Buster Challenge:Password: ricehttps://fantasy.espn.com/tc/sharer?challengeId=277&from=espn&context=GROUP_INVITE&edition=espn-en&groupId=1d5c28
- S2E2 D&C 41 Part 1In this episode, we discuss the early Ohio period of Church history, setting the stage for Doctrine and Covenants 41 by exploring the sacrifices required of the Saints as they gathered to Kirtland and the difficult realities facing new converts who had to leave behind property, security, and deeply held religious assumptions.Please join us in our Standard of Truth Dead and in Hell March Madness Challenge:Password: ricehttps://fantasy.espn.com/tc/sharer?challengeId=277&from=espn&context=GROUP_INV
- S3E4 The Three-Fifths CompromiseSlavery doesn’t dominate the Constitutional Convention the way modern listeners expect, not because it wasn’t evil or important, but because the delegates are obsessing over a different fight: how representation will work, who counts in the census, and how taxation should track with political power. That technical argument is exactly where slavery gets dragged onto the floor. Gerrit walks through the convention minutes, and introduces the listener to General Pinckney.If you lived back then, woul
- S3E3 Discussion of Slavery at the Constitutional ConventionIn this episode, we begin with a description about how people make decisions based on the world right in front of them with super topical examples like Blockbuster, BlackBerry, Pony Express, and Redbox.From there we get into what the delegates thought was going to happen with population growth, representation, and slavery, and why so many of their assumptions ended up being wrong. We also talk through the messy reality that slavery existed in every state, that some northern states started abolis
- S3E4 - Orson Hyde's Account of the Angel Moroni and the First VisionIn this episode, go back into early Restoration history with an important source most listeners have never read: Orson Hyde’s early German missionary tract. Gerrit takes a slight detour into one of the show’s recurring themes: why some critics keep treating John C. Bennett like a trustworthy source, despite him being a lying liar and fornicating fornicator.Hyde’s account frames Joseph Smith’s early life and limited education, the religious confusion that pushed Joseph to James 1:5, and the First
- S3E2 - Constitutional Convention Nearly Falls Apart Over RepresentationWe discuss the most persistent tensions in American political history: representation, power, and who actually gets a voice in a federal system. Gerrit and Richard bounce from Gouverneur Morris to the Electoral College, the Three-Fifths Compromise, modern elections, and Senate rules to show how arguments that feel uniquely “today” are really old problems wearing new clothes. The core theme is that history rarely resolves itself cleanly, and when we strip events of their context or cherry-pick st
- S3E3 - Orson Pratt's Account of the Angel Moroni and the First VisionIn this episode we review an 1840s missionary tract by Orson Pratt, An Interesting Account of Several Remarkable Visions and of the Late Discovery of Ancient American Records. Gerrit walks through Pratt’s retelling of the First Vision. Pratt highlights Joseph’s fear of trusting salvation to “chance,” takes denominational disagreement seriously, and frames the First Vision as an answer to a real theological problem: if churches teach opposing doctrines about salvation, authority, and ordinances,
- S3E2 The Temptation of Joseph SmithWe pick up Oliver Cowdery’s account of Moroni’s visitation and the events of September 21–22, 1823, where Cowdery promises not to digress and then immediately does. We discuss Joseph Smith’s temptation as he walks to the hill, torn between God’s command and the very real possibility that a record of gold could rescue his impoverished family. Drawing on Cowdery’s letters and Joseph’s later history, we explore why this wasn’t a cartoonish moral failure but a subtle, powerful test of motives, culmi
- S3E1 - Oliver Cowdery and MoroniAfter more than a year away, Gerrit and Richard return to Joseph Smith and the Restoration with a discussion of Oliver Cowdery's famously digressive letters about the First Vision and Moroni's appearance.In this episode, we explore Oliver Cowdery's 1834-1835 letter series describing Moroni's visit to Joseph Smith, discovering that Cowdery's writing style makes their own tangents look modest by comparison. Between discussions of NBA draft picks, Caleb Williams, exercise ball kneeling records, and
- S3E1 - Toilet Paper, Gouverneur Morris, and the Constitutional ConventionCondemned to Repeat It is finally back and we return to the Constitutional Convention and pick up right where they left off.This episode centers on one of the most entertaining, complicated, and frankly chaotic delegates in Philadelphia: Gouverneur Morris. He’s wealthy, brilliant, scandal-prone, relentlessly talkative, and allergic to sentimental political speeches. Morris doesn’t pretend public officials will act out of pure virtue. He assumes vice is guaranteed, and asks: How do you build a go
- S2E1 D&C 39 and 40 Part 2Season 2 kicks off with part 2 of Doctrine and Covenants 39 and 40 with the tragic story of James Covel: a seasoned minister who covenants to obey whatever the Lord commands, receives a revelation calling him to be baptized and gather to Ohio, then walks away the very next day. We discuss why fear of persecution and “the cares of the world” can choke faith, and how these sections force the question: am I willing to follow revelation when it costs me something?Standard of Truth Tour dates for the
- S1E54 D&C 39 and 40 Part 1The core of the discussion is the mysterious figure behind Section 39, James Covel. For decades, Latter-day Saint scholarship identified him as a Baptist minister, largely because later printed sources said so, but more recent manuscript evidence complicates that story, suggesting he may have actually been a local Methodist preacher. Gerrit walks listeners through how the Church’s earliest revelation manuscripts and indexes have reshaped what we think we know, and why that matters for reading th
- S1E53 D&C 38Using John Whitmer’s contemporary framing, Gerrit shows how the Saints weren’t merely “moving” to Ohio, they were being commanded to flee, amid escalating threats, arrests, and what the Lord calls “a mystery… had in secret chambers” seeking their destruction. The episode explores why the Lord begins this revelation by declaring His identity and power, then pivots immediately to unity, consecration, and the sobering demand that the Saints leave behind property, status, and security to follow Him.
- S1E52 D&C 37 Part 2Building on last week’s deep dive into the persecution of the Colesville Saints, this episode explores why the Lord’s command to “assemble at the Ohio” was so disruptive and spiritually revealing. Gerrit walks through Joseph Smith’s own accounts of mobs, arrests, midnight escapes, and the relentless sectarian hostility that shaped the emotional landscape behind D&C 37. Clayton Christensen: How Will You Measure Your Lifehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvos4nORf_YStandard of Truth Tour dates for t
- S1E51 D&C 37 Part 1In this episode, we provide the context for D&C 37. We discuss the charges against Joseph Smith’s of being a “disorderly person” and the carefully coordinated plan between mob and local officials to get Joseph into custody so they could assault or even kill him. We share Newel Knight’s and Joseph Knight Sr.’s firsthand accounts of the mobs, the destroyed baptismal dam, and the all-day trials.Subscribe to our free newsletter - https://standardoftruthpodcast.substack.com/Please visit our web