Holiday offer: Get up to 3 memberships free for 1 month. Valid thru Dec 16.

See the offer
Podcast membership

Forgotten True Crime

Ways to join

  • Forgotten True Crime

    $3.00/month

    • Ad-free listening

For members only

130 episodes

  • Carving Season · Paul Michael Merhige - The Jupiter Thanksgiving Shootings

    Ad-freeNov 1652 min

    Thanksgiving night, 2009. Jupiter, Florida, at the very top of Palm Beach County. At six minutes past ten, a woman calls 911. She's just heard gunshots, about ten of them, and then people screaming. And somewhere in the middle of it, a woman's voice yelling three words: "Get the kids."Earlier that same evening, inside that house, a family had been singing around a piano. Grandparents and parents, aunts and uncles and cousins, and a little girl, not quite seven, who had recited a psalm for all of
  • The Killing of John Gorrell, Part 2: A Roman Holiday

    Ad-freeNov 1478 min

    February 1935. Pawnee, Oklahoma. The trial has been moved out of Tulsa, and the town fills up anyway: reporters, wire photographers, and a crowd that pushes through the courthouse doors to get a seat. At one table sits a federal judge and his son. Across from them sits a Tulsa dentist whose son has been dead for eleven weeks.When the state calls Dr. J. F. Gorrell to the stand, they ask him one question that matters. Is your son living or dead?Then the defense brings out a letter. Phil Kennamer t
  • Carving Season · The Murder of Greg Nickell

    Ad-freeNov 1249 min

    Thanksgiving weekend, 1972. Greg Nickell was 21, home in Vernal, Utah, after thirteen months in Vietnam. He'd broken a date that Saturday night so his sister's friend, visiting from Idaho, wouldn't be left out. After a dance, the two of them drove out to the scenic overlook on U.S. 40, west of town, to see the valley. A man came to the window and said he needed help.Greg said sure.By dawn on Sunday, an 18-year-old girl was running down the highway toward a farmhouse near Duchesne, on the far sid
  • Carving Season: The Murder of Hildegard Clark

    Ad-freeNov 974 min

    Thanksgiving night, 1949. Bethel Island, out in the Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta. Two sheriff's deputies pull up in front of a small cottage at twenty-five past seven. A woman is lying on the front lawn, where she's been since about four o'clock. Inside, the potatoes for the day's dinner are still cooking on the stove, and the table has been set and, in the paper's words, "gaily decorated."Nobody ever sat down to that dinner.Next door, five of her guests have been hiding for three hours, afraid
  • The Killing of John Gorrell, Part 1: Keep Your Mouth Shut

    Ad-freeNov 767 min

    Thanksgiving night, 1934. Tulsa, Oklahoma. In the back of the Owl Tavern, two doors from the Quaker Drug Store, nineteen-year-old Phil Kennamer, a federal judge's son, opens his coat to show a friend the hunting knife on his belt. He has a date tonight, he says. With Gorrell. At eleven o'clock.He walks out the front door and yells back that he'll be back in five minutes. He never does come back.For nine days before that night, Phil had been telling his friends what he was going to do. He showed