Ways to join
Almost Fiction
$2.99/month
- Bonus episodes
For members only
23 episodes
- Joel Michael Guy Jr. AD FREEWhen 28-year-old Joel Michael Guy Jr. learned his parents were cutting off his financial support after nearly a decade of funding his lifestyle, he devised a horrifying plan. This deep-dive true crime investigation uncovers how an entitled college dropout meticulously plotted to murder his own parents for a $500,000 insurance payout, only to be caught by his own incompetence and the security cameras he most likely never knew existed.Sources: STATE OF TENNESSEE v. JOEL MICHAEL GUY, JR. Appeal fro
- Plus: Peter Britton TobinA restless predator with 60+ addresses, 40+ aliases, and 150+ vehicles. Peter Britton Tobin's decades-long trail of violence across Scotland and England reveals the chilling reality of a serial killer who never stopped moving. From his brutal attacks on wives to the murders of three young women, this episode traces the methodical police investigation that finally caught a monster. This is another episode of Almost Fiction Plus, a show for our most loyal supporters.
- Robert Yale Shulman AD FREEBetween 1991 and 1995, a seemingly ordinary postal worker living in suburban New York concealed a horrifying secret. Robert Yale Shulman targeted vulnerable sex workers, brutally murdering at least five women before dismembering their bodies and disposing of them in dumpsters across the region. This is the chilling true story of how a shy, introverted mail handler became one of New York's most brutal serial killers, and how dogged detective work finally brought him to justice.This episode examin
- Robert Zarinsky Part 2 AD FREEWhen Officer Charles Bernoskie was gunned down during a routine patrol in 1958, his murder went unsolved for decades, protected by a family's deadly silence. This is the conclusion to the story of Robert Zarinsky, a serial killer who terrorized New Jersey communities throughout the 1960s and 70s, leaving behind a trail of young women who simply seemed to just vanish without a trace.This gripping tale reveals how one mother's obsession with appearances and family loyalty created a monster, how DN
- Robert Zarinsky Part 1 AD FREEWhen Officer Charles Bernoskie was gunned down during a routine patrol in 1958, his murder went unsolved for decades, protected by a family's deadly silence. This is the chilling true story of Robert Zarinsky, a serial killer who terrorized New Jersey communities throughout the 1960s and 70s, leaving behind a trail of young women who simply vanished.From the disappearance of 17-year-old Rosemary Calandriello in 1969 to the brutal murders of Jane Durrua, Linda Balabanow, and others, Zarinsky's re
- Plus: James TennerDive into the chilling true crime case of James Tenner, a volatile man whose domestic violence escalated into a calculated triple murder in 1987. When his relationship with his girlfriend crumbled, Tenner blamed his friends for ruining his life. What followed was a premeditated attack involving nooses, hostages, and point-blank executions in a South Chicago Heights garage. This episode explores how unchecked violence can spiral into unthinkable tragedy, and how sometimes its better to just cut t
- The Murder of Peter Aston AD FREEIn May 1982, two thirteen-year-old boys skipped school in Queensland, Australia, a decision that led one to his brutal death and the other to a nightmare of survival. When Peter Aston and Terry Ryan accepted a ride from two men, they had no idea they were entering a world of sadistic violence, a world of unimaginable pain. What followed became one of Australia's most disturbing crimes: hours of torture, sexual abuse, and murder that would leave one boy dead and another forever traumatized. This
- Robert R. Reldan AD FREERobert R. Reldan had everything. Looks, charm, and money from a wealthy aunt who adored him. But in October 1975, two women named Susan disappeared from Bergen County only eight days apart. What followed exposed a decades-long pattern: assaults dismissed, paroles granted, a system that kept giving second chances to someone who shouldn't have gotten them in the first place.It's a story about privilege, the cost of looking the other way, and two families who refused to let their Susans ever be for
- Herb Baumeister AD FREEA successful businessman. A perfect suburban address. And a trail of vanished men that led investigators to more than 10,000 human remains. In this episode, we trace Herb Baumeister’s double life—from teenage transgressions to “Brian Smart,” his nights cruising Indianapolis’s gay bars, the discoveries at Fox Hollow Farm, and the investigators who wouldn’t let the case go. We examine what’s known, what’s still conjecture, and why so many families still wait for answers.
- George Waterfield Russell AD FREEDive into the chilling true story of George Waterfield Russell Jr., a man whose repeated rejections fueled a deadly rage against women. From his abandoned childhood in Florida to a string of brutal murders in 1990s Washington State, this episode uncovers the twisted path of a serial killer who staged his victims in horrifying poses. Explore the investigations, key evidence, and trial that brought him to justice. Listen now and subscribe for more gripping tales, as well as ad-free options availab
- AD FREE - Earl Richmond Jr.AD FREE EPISODEExplore the haunting case of Earl Richmond Jr., a former drill sergeant whose life unraveled through addiction, rape, and murder. From his abusive upbringing in North Carolina to brutal crimes at Fort Dix and beyond, this episode unpacks the evidence, trials, and his execution, while questioning if true redemption is possible after unthinkable evil.*To hear this episode early and ad free version simply join sign up on Spotify for only 3 dollars a month. You'll also get access to b
- Plus: Ricky Lee SandersonIn 1985, 16-year-old Sue Ellen “Suzi” Holliman vanished from her North Carolina home. A month later, her body was found, and the wrong man confessed. This episode traces the brutal crime, the forensic trail that pointed elsewhere, and the extraordinary turn when Ricky Lee Sanderson, already serving life, called authorities to confess. Was it faith, strategy, or something in between? We present the record: the childhood that shaped him, the crimes he admitted, and the legal path that led to North
- AD FREE LaFonda "Fay" Foster and Tina Marie Hickey PowellAD FREE VERSIONIn this episode, we explore the complexities of friendship, focusing on trust and mutual respect. Highlighting the tragic story of Tina Marie Powell and LaFonda Faye Foster, we illustrate how their bond, rooted in shared trauma and addiction, devolved into toxicity and violence.We recount the harrowing events of April 23, 1986, in Lexington, Kentucky, where a night of drinking led to a devastating crime spree. The episode examines the psychological motives behind their actions and
- Plus: Charles Edward TerryWelcome to Almost Fiction Plus, exclusive Almost Fiction episodes, dedicated to our supporters.You keep the lights on and the bills paid. So for those of you who help us do what we do, we wanted to do a little something special. As always, I’m Chase Ellerman, and this is Almost Fiction… Plus. Enjoy.
- Plus: Alonzo RobinsonThis case has a little bit of everything. I wish that there was more information, I wish there was more to find on this story, but what is available is enough to see that people like Ed Gien aren’t one of a kind.
- Plus: Tyree Lincoln SmithRituals span across every country, every religion, and every group. No matter what you are a part of, there are going to be rituals and practices that you follow, sometimes without even realizing it. This week we follow the case of a man who wanted to perform an ancient ritual, one now banned in almost every civilized country. This is the story of Tyree Lincoln Smith.
- Plus: Michael Duane ZachSome people are… magnetic, easily able to attach themselves to others, drawing them in with relative ease with their larger than life personalities. There are just some people who can talk to anyone, make them feel at ease, quickly transitioning from stranger to acquaintance, to… friend.
- Plus: William WallaceNo, not that William Wallace. For a lot of people, the holiday season can be a time of happiness, togetherness, and joy. A time full of family, laughter, and good will, but for others, the holiday season can have the opposite effect.
- Plus: Christopher RicheeChristopher Richee wanted to commit the perfect crime, and in December of 1996 he thought that he had finally accomplished it... But, he hadn’t. Welcome to another episode of Almost Fiction Plus, an exclusive show for our supporters.
- Plus: Brian David SteckelWelcome to another episode of Almost Fiction Plus. This week we talk about the case of Brian David Steckel and his victim Sandra Lee Long. Thank you for your ongoing support and please enjoy this exclusive episode of Almost Fiction.
- Plus: Barbara Marie OpelBarbara Marie Opel wanted something that was not hers, and in April of 2001, she thought that she had finally found a way to get rich quick… But, she hadn’t. Welcome to another episode of Almost Fiction Plus, an exclusive show for our supporters.
- Plus: Brittany Marlowe HolbergWelcome to another episode of Almost Fiction Plus. Thank you to all of our supporters who keep the bills paid and the lights on.
- Plus: Jose Santellan Sr.Dive into the dark saga of Jose Santellan Sr., a repeat offender whose life of burglary, assault, and prison escapes culminated in a horrifying act of vengeance. In 1993, fueled by obsession, he gunned down ex-girlfriend Yolanda Garza in a Texas hospital parking lot then abducted her body for one final, twisted reunion. Uncover his chilling confessions, necrophilic crimes, turbulent trials, and path to the death chamber in this gripping bonus episode of Almost Fiction. True crime fans: explore o